IQNA

16:01 - October 05, 2026
News ID: 3499287

Andalus: When History Cannot Be Erased

IQNA – From Spain to Sicily, Muslims helped shape Europe for centuries. Why do they still seem to be cast as outsiders?

From Al-Andalus to Gaza: When History Cannot Be Erased

 

Author Tariq Ali has traced the rise of al-Andalus to its fall amid the burning of books and the loss of a shared past.

The history of Al-Andalus is not simply a story about the rise and fall of Muslim rule in the Iberian Peninsula. For British-Pakistani historian and writer Tariq Ali, it is also a story about memory, identity, cultural destruction and the ways in which the past continues to shape the politics of the present.

In a wide-ranging conversation, Ali reflects on the centuries-long history of Muslim Spain, the expulsion and forced conversion of Muslims, the destruction of manuscripts, the intellectual exchanges that helped shape Europe, and the persistence of historical memory despite attempts to erase it. He also draws a line between the experience of Muslims expelled from Spain and the contemporary experience of Palestinians facing displacement and dispossession.

The destruction of a civilization’s memory

Muslim forces entered southern Spain in 711, beginning a period that would eventually produce one of the most influential cultural and intellectual societies of medieval Europe. Centuries later, the Christian Reconquista culminated in the fall of Granada in 1492, bringing Muslim political rule in Iberia to an end.

But according to Ali, the end of Muslim political power was followed by an attempt to eliminate the cultural and linguistic traces of Muslim society.

He recalls that in Granada, in 1499, Christian forces publicly burned vast numbers of Muslim manuscripts. For Ali, the destruction of books was not merely the destruction of physical objects. It represented an attempt to destroy collective memory, language and culture.

Yet history proved more difficult to erase than its conquerors had anticipated.

During his research in Spain, Ali encountered Arabic-derived place names and oral memories preserved within Spanish families. One elderly woman told him that her ancestors had been tied up, transported and sent to North Africa. Her family had been Muslim and had been forced to convert or leave.

These encounters became part of the inspiration for his novel Shadows of the Pomegranate Tree. Ali argues that the effort to erase Muslim identity through the destruction of language, culture and historical records could never completely succeed because memory survived within families and communities.

Al-Andalus and the memory of coexistence

Ali also challenges simplified portrayals of Al-Andalus as either an idealized paradise or an era of permanent conflict. He points to periods in which Muslims, Christians and Jews lived together and, at times, formed political alliances that crossed religious boundaries.

The Alhambra, he argues, stands as one of the most powerful symbols of the final flowering of Islamic civilization in Spain. The legacy of Al-Andalus was not limited to Muslim communities. Jewish intellectuals and officials occupied important positions under Muslim rule, while many Jews who fled Spain after 1492 eventually found refuge in the Ottoman Empire.

Ali also emphasizes that the Muslims of Al-Andalus were not simply foreign Arabs ruling over a European population. Many were local converts who had become part of the Muslim society of Iberia.

He recalls the case of a Spanish king who rejected a proposal to send Spanish Muslims to work as slaves in mines in the Americas, arguing that they were Spaniards as well. For Ali, such episodes complicate the conventional image of Muslims as an entirely foreign population that disappeared from Spain after the Reconquista.

The memory of expulsion also appears, according to Ali, in European literature. He points to Miguel de Cervantes’ Don Quixote, arguing that traces of the Muslim expulsion and the historical trauma surrounding it survived in the work despite the censorship imposed by the Inquisition.

For Ali, this provides another example of how historical experiences can remain embedded in a society even when official institutions attempt to suppress them. He also connects this historical experience with the Palestinian question, where displacement and the struggle over historical memory remain central issues.

65

How Islamic knowledge helped shape Europe

Ali rejects the idea that Europe’s intellectual development can be understood without taking into account the knowledge transmitted through the Muslim world.

Islamic civilization, he notes, was connected to wider intellectual networks extending beyond Spain. Sicily, for example, became another important point of contact between Muslim and Christian societies.

Greek philosophical works that had been translated into Arabic were preserved, studied and developed by Muslim scholars before many of them were later translated into Latin and entered European intellectual life.

Ali also points to advances in mathematics and medicine. Algebra, in particular, is presented as one of the important contributions associated with the Arab-Islamic intellectual tradition. He also refers to the influence of Muslim medical knowledge on Europe and to Salerno as an important site in the development of early European medicine and hospital institutions.

In this reading, the European Renaissance did not emerge in complete isolation. It was also connected to centuries of intellectual exchange across the Mediterranean.

Beyond the “clash of civilizations”

Ali strongly rejects the argument that relations between Islam and the West are inevitably defined by a “clash of civilizations.”

He argues that many of the great conflicts in European history were not wars between separate civilizations but struggles over power, territory, wealth and political control. The history of Catholic and Protestant Europe itself demonstrates that religious identity alone cannot explain political conflict.

The history of Sicily, where Muslims and Norman Christians sometimes cooperated, offers another example of alliances that crossed religious boundaries.

After the September 11 attacks, Ali wrote The Clash of Fundamentalisms, in which he examined what he saw as the interaction between different forms of political and religious fundamentalism.

He draws a comparison between Islamic fundamentalist movements such as al-Qaeda and ISIS and what he describes as an evangelical and imperial form of fundamentalism associated with the administration of George W. Bush and Dick Cheney.

In his view, both can rely on selective and idealized versions of history. But there is an important difference: state-backed fundamentalism has access to vastly greater military and political power, making its consequences potentially much more destructive.

65

Islamophobia and the politics of scapegoating

Ali places the contemporary rise of Islamophobia within a broader political and economic crisis in Europe and the United States.

He points to nationalist and far-right movements, including Germany’s AfD, the political system associated with Viktor Orbán in Hungary, MAGA politics in the United States and the British far right. These movements, he argues, frequently rely on narratives portraying Muslims and immigrants as threats to the existing national identity.

The idea of a “great replacement” is one manifestation of this politics: social and economic anxieties are transformed into fear of demographic change, with Muslims often presented as a convenient target.

Ali compares some contemporary anti-Muslim rhetoric with the anti-Jewish rhetoric that appeared in parts of the British media during the 1930s. His broader argument is that societies experiencing political dissatisfaction and economic insecurity often search for groups to blame.

Immigrants can therefore become scapegoats not simply because of their origins or religion, but because they become convenient targets for wider frustrations.

At the same time, Ali notes that successful immigrants can also generate resentment when they become politically influential or achieve positions of social prominence.

Economics behind the politics of exclusion

For Ali, prejudice cannot be separated from economic conditions.

He argues that periods of relatively strong employment historically tend to reduce the political visibility of hostility toward immigrants, while economic insecurity can intensify the search for scapegoats.

This argument forms part of a broader critique of the contemporary capitalist political system. In his view, attacks on immigration and the political response to the Gaza war reveal deeper contradictions within Western politics.

He also identifies China’s economic rise as one of the central developments of the 21st century, challenging the traditional Western assumption that capitalism and liberal democracy necessarily develop together.

65

From Al-Andalus to Palestine

The historical memory of Al-Andalus takes on a contemporary political meaning when Ali discusses Palestine.

The connection is particularly visible through the themes of expulsion, dispossession and the struggle to preserve identity. The Muslims who were expelled from Spain could, at least in many cases, seek refuge elsewhere. Palestinians facing displacement today confront a different reality: many have no secure homeland to which they can return.

Ali describes conversations with Palestinian friends who feel that they no longer belong, while at the same time having nowhere safe to go.

He also speaks from personal experience about displacement. He recalls being expelled from France, the United States, Turkey and Germany during the 1960s, but says that he never felt that he should leave Britain. For him, departure would have meant accepting defeat.

His message to Palestinians and others facing political pressure is therefore not to panic or abandon their societies. Resistance, he argues, can take many forms: writing, organizing, trade union activity, political campaigning and participation in anti-war demonstrations.

The past should not become a prison

Yet Ali also warns against turning the memory of Al-Andalus into pure nostalgia.

Remembering the past, he argues, should not mean attempting to live permanently in a vanished era. Muslims should not simply look backward toward Al-Andalus as a lost golden age. The more important question is what can be learned from history and brought into the present.

He poses the question of what elements of the past can be taken out, preserved and “planted again” in a new historical environment. The past can provide resources for the future, but it cannot replace the present.

For Ali, this is ultimately the central lesson of the history of Al-Andalus. Civilizations do not disappear simply because political authorities declare that they have ended. Their languages, memories, ideas and cultural influences can survive long after political power has vanished.

The same principle applies to contemporary conflicts over identity and belonging. Attempts to erase a people’s history may destroy archives, books and institutions, but they cannot necessarily eliminate memory.

The story of Al-Andalus therefore remains relevant not because it belongs to a distant medieval past, but because questions of coexistence, expulsion, identity, cultural memory and political belonging remain unresolved in the present.

In Ali’s reading, the lesson is not simply to mourn what was lost. It is to understand history well enough to decide what should be carried forward—and what kind of future should be built for the next generation.

Source: Aljazeera

Tags: Andalus ، islam ، christian ، jews
captcha