IQNA

16:39 - October 27, 2026
News ID: 3499562

Expert Questions Malaysia Quran Contest’s Reputation, Demands Score Transparency

IQNA – An Iranian Quran reciter and international judge has challenged the reputation of Malaysia's international Quran competition, arguing it is not consistently the world-class event it is made out to be—and calling for the release of detailed scores to settle doubts about the results in this year’s edition of the contest.

Amin Pouya

 

Amin Pouya made the remarks at a specialized panel hosted by the International Quran News Agency (IQNA). The session was titled “Iranian Recitation on the Scales of Global Competition” and focused on Iran’s participation in the annual Malaysia international Quran competition.

Pouya opened his remarks by challenging the assumption that age equals quality.

“Are the oldest always the best? Are the oldest always the highest quality?” he asked. “In every field—art, industry—technology and products keep advancing. Those who do not work on quality and do not update themselves fall behind.”

He also questioned how much weight Iran gives to certain competitions. “How much importance do we attach to some contests? And based on that importance, we create sensitivity—and through that sensitivity, we inflate the value of the competition itself,” he said. “Perhaps it is not worth as much as we make it out to be.”

Pouya, who competed in the Malaysia international Quran competition twice, said the contest’s quality has fluctuated.

“The level of competitors in the men’s recitation section in Malaysia has at times been the highest in the world,” he said. “But has that been true in every year and every edition?”

He said the 2006 and 2007 editions were weak, 2012 was average, and this year’s field was strong, with five or six reciters performing well. He added that Iran’s representative recited very well and, in his view as a reciter, judge and expert, deserved first place.

Pouya said Malaysia should not be assumed to be the pinnacle. In the same years he competed in Malaysia, he also took part in Russia’s Quran competition, where he found the recitation quality higher and the field larger.

“I won first place in Russia that year, while Malaysia's representative came third,” he said. ”But that same Malaysian reciter, when he competed in Malaysia in 2012 with the same quality he showed in Russia, took first place in his own country.”

He offered another example: in 2006, Malaysia’s representative was eliminated early at a competition in India for a low-level performance—then won first place in Malaysia the following year.

“When you have competed in Tunisia, Russia or India, you realize it is not true that only Malaysia’s contest is (always) high-level,” he said. “Sometimes its level is lower than these others.”

Pouya questioned why the Islamic Republic of Iran Broadcasting (IRIB) sends a team to cover Malaysia’s competition while other contests receive less attention. “If a group from IRIB is sent to cover Malaysia’s contest, that means they attach great importance to it,” he said. “Are the other competitions not important?”

Read More:

He said reducing the outsized sensitivity around Malaysia—among the public and among reciters—is a prerequisite for any alternative strategy, such as using social media to showcase talent. He made the point in response to an earlier proposal at the panel that reciters could gain visibility online rather than through international contests.

Pouya also raised doubts about the fairness of Malaysia’s judging. He noted that some judges are invited from countries where they have no background in Quran recitation, with their only professional experience being as commentators.

He called on the head of the judging panel or the competition’s organizers to release the detailed scores of Iran’s representative and the top three finishers in the men’s recitation section.

“… for the sake of transparency and to inform public opinion, I request that they publish the detailed scores so that all doubts (about the fairness in evaluations) can be removed,” he said.

  

4384595

 

captcha